Socrates
| Heaven on Their Minds | Judas | Sextus Empiricus | Forms on their minds |
| What's the Buzz / Strange Thing Mystifying | Apostles, Jesus, Mary, Judas, Peter, Woman | Apostles, Socrates, ?, ?, Xanthippe? | |
| Everything's Alright | Mary, Women, Judas, Jesus, Apostles | Glaucon, Socrates, Thrasymachus | Socrates is right |
| This Jesus Must Die | Annas, Caiaphas, Apostles, Priests | Anytus & Meletus | Socrates must die |
| Hosanna | Apostles, Caiaphas, Jesus | ||
| Simon Zealotes / Poor Jerusalem | Apostles, Simon, Jesus, Ensemble | Critias | |
| Pilate's Dream | Pilate | ||
| The Temple | Jesus | Socrates | The Cave |
| Everything's Alright (reprise) | Mary, Jesus | Glaucon, Socrates | Socrates, you're right |
| I Don't Know How to Love Him | Mary | Alcibiades | Same title |
| Damned For All Time / Blood Money | Judas, Annas, Caiaphas | ||
| The Last Supper | Apostles, Jesus, Judas | ||
| Gethsemane | Jesus | Socrates | |
| The Arrest | Judas, Jesus, Peter, Apostles, Annas, Caiaphas | ||
| Peter's Denial | Maid by the Fire, Peter, Soldier, Old Man, Mary | ||
| Pilate and Christ | Pilate, Soldier, Jesus | ||
| King Herod's Song | Herod, Dancers | ||
| Could We Start Again Please? | Mary, Apostles, Peter | Glaucon, Plato, other pupils | |
| Judas' Death | Judas, Annas, Caiaphas | ||
| Trial Before Pilate | Pilate, Caiaphas, Jesus | ? | Apology |
| Superstar | Judas, Soul Sisters, Angels | ||
| The Crucifixion | Jesus |